Skip to main content

Loading Search Form

Please Wait

Nicki Donlin Lic Assoc RE Broker

#youshouldcallnicki


Nicki is consistently among the top agents in Central New York and Howard Hanna Real Estate... From the City of Syracuse, to the beautiful lakeside community of Cazenovia, to Hamilton- home of Colgate University, and everywhere in between! Since 2002, Nicki has been a leader in the area by providing the best online presence for real estate advice, supporting local business, or sharing personal happenings and home listings... Nicki is truly a trusted and friendly resource for all of Central New York.
As two-time all-American athlete at Ithaca College, Nicki prides herself on having that winning edge. That confidence and competitive nature, combined with genuine care for her clients, is a recipe for success.
Nicki is a life-long resident of Central New York, growing up in Hamilton and residing in Cazenovia since 2000. With her husband, Mike, and their two children, Jack and Will, Nicki loves selling Cazenovia and the CNY lifestyle.

 

Real Estate Highlights:

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson since 2003

Member of the National Association of Realtors, New York State Association of Realtors, and Greater Syracuse Association of Realtors

Champions Club Award Winner 

National Sales Excellence Award Winner

Personal Highlights:

Member of the St. Joseph's Auxiliary Board of Directors
Ithaca College Athletics Hall of Fame
Hamilton Central School Hall of Honor

Notes:

Specializing in Cazenovia, DeWitt, Jamesville, Fayetteville, Manlius, Hamilton 

Nearly two decades of experience with waterfront properties, farms, equine properties, land, village, country and new construction.

Market leader in online marketing - buyers and sellers have a clear advantage through both online and traditional marketing, and social media.  Sellers get more exposure and buyers get more information!  Nicki has become a trusted online resource for thousands of online visitors daily.

@YouShouldCallNicki

 

 


Specialties

Hanna Luxury
Farm And Ranch
First Time Buyers
Historic Home
Luxury Homes
Military
Waterfront Properties

Photo for Shephard Road $150,000 Sold 7/24/2026
Buyer's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

Courtesy of:
Canaan Realty
MLS # S1679019
Photo for 3903 Nelson Heights Road $609,000 Sold 7/14/2026
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
2,240
Buyer's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

Courtesy of:
Oak Tree Real Estate
315-657-0473
MLS # S1679273
Photo for 62 Broad Street $749,000 Sold 7/13/2026
beds
 
5
full
baths
3
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
4,306
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
Buyer's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1678694
Photo for 21 Fenner Street $180,000 Sold 7/13/2026
beds
 
2
full
bath
1
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,100
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1679820
Photo for 7499 Bonney Hill Road $410,000 Sold 6/29/2026
beds
 
5
full
baths
2
sq.ft.
 
2,225
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
Buyer's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1673240
Photo for 4579 Red Fox Drive $385,000 Sold 6/24/2026
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,837
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1672868
Photo for 5278 Hill Road $710,000 Sold 6/10/2026
beds
 
4
full
baths
3
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
3,100
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1663752
Photo for 22 Atwell Ridge Road $108,000 Sold 6/9/2026
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1659082
Photo for 24 Atwell Ridge Road $108,000 Sold 6/9/2026
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1659136
Photo for 104 Holly Circle $600,000 Sold 4/20/2026
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
2,592
Buyer's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1659920
Photo for 2119 Ten Eyck Avenue $650,000 Sold 3/18/2026
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,984
Buyer's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1659207
Photo for Old State Road $10,000 Sold 1/23/2026
Photo for 6323 Danbury Drive $377,400 Sold 12/23/2025
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,724
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1645499
Photo for 8371 Salt Springs Road $670,000 Sold 12/12/2025
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
3,034
Buyer's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

Courtesy of:
Hunt Real Estate ERA
MLS # S1621982
Photo for 612 Church Street $199,000 Sold 12/8/2025
beds
 
2
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
840
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1637115
Photo for 109 Terrace Circle $165,000 Sold 12/8/2025
beds
 
2
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,146
Buyer's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

Courtesy of:
Cedar Bay Real Estate
MLS # S1636610
Photo for 4729 Roberts Road $390,000 Sold 11/30/2025
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
partial
baths
2
sq.ft.
 
1,680
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1626559
Photo for 4628 Red Fox Drive $349,500 Sold 11/24/2025
beds
 
5
full
baths
3
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
2,725
MLS # S1626865
Photo for 435 Brody Drive $210,000 Sold 11/14/2025
beds
 
3
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
912
Buyer's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1623526
Photo for 8174 Old Sunridge Drive $439,900 Sold 11/11/2025
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
3,942
Seller's Agent:Nicki Donlin
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # S1628921
Hanna Luxury

Have a question?
I can help.

Are you pre-approved for a mortgage?

By submitting this request, you agree to be contacted by Howard Hanna via call, email, and text for real estate, mortgage, insurance, and professional services but not as a condition of any purchase. To opt out, you can reply 'stop' at any time or reply 'help' for assistance. You can also click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. You will receive a text message asking you to authenticate your phone number. Message/data rates may apply. This consent applies even if you are on a corporate, state, or national Do Not Call list. You can also click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. You also agree with our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy regarding the information relating to you. Your phone number, if you choose mobile opt-in data, will not be shared with third parties for marketing purposes. You can also view our privacy policy here: Policy Link