Skip to main content

Loading Search Form

Please Wait

Karen Small Lic. RE Salesperson


Karen Small is an interesting person with life experience to spare. She is also one heck of a smart, dedicated Realtor.

Originally from the Albany area, she earned a BFA in theater design and technology and costume design from SUNY Purchase, moved to Brooklyn before it was even fashionable, and spent 15 years working in technical theater in New York City, including 14 years designing costumes for Jennifer Muller/The Works Dance, and seven years managing Izquierdo Studio, a costume, prop, and set-design studio. In those roles, she earned her stripes for her resourcefulness, integrity, and unparalleled professionalism. She also bought and renovated an 1800s Italianate four-story townhouse, which led her to develop a passion for real estate.

Her experience in the fast-paced world of costume design and production prepared her well for the creativity and dedication needed to effectively market client properties and to help buyers find their ideal homes.  After more than fifteen years working in the Ithaca area’s real estate market, she knows it well. She is well liked by her peers, despite being a tough negotiator.

But these recommendations from just a few of her many clients say it all:

“I've been working with Karen for nearly 10 years buying and selling multiple houses and I can say, without a doubt, that Karen is one of the best agents in town! Her dedication, work ethic, and extensive knowledge of both the local area and the intricacies of real estate hoop jumping, are unparalleled. What makes Karen even more unique are her character and ethics around her profession. . . I would recommend her wholeheartedly to anyone interested in buying or selling real estate in the Ithaca area!”

“Karen helped my family find and purchase the perfect house! We are a low income family and received a grant to help purchase our home. This required us to meet very which also presented its own unique sets of challenges. Every step of the process presented challenges, and working as a team we overcame them all. Karen and I spent many late nights working out the problems, above and beyond anything I would expect from someone in her position. She also provided so much needed moral support when things got tough or new problems arose. I truly believe we could not have purchased this house without her help. . . Karen works very hard for her clients, it was such a great experience working with her and we are very grateful for everything she did for us.”

“We worked with Karen to buy a house and to sell my condo, and she was fantastic in both roles. She was always available for questions, she knows the local markets, she understood our need to sequence the purchase and the sale, and she quickly learned what we liked. . . She has good contacts with all those who become part of selling and purchasing (inspectors, radon testing, other realtors, etc.). And, she was even able to recommend a fantastic local mover. We expected a lot of Karen, and she not only met, but exceeded our expectations.”

“Karen Small knows everything. She is equally savvy about the vagaries of the market, structural engineering, interior design, and a million other things unrelated to real estate. She shepherded us through every step of buying our first home and we couldn't have been happier -- she understood our needs exactly, answered all our questions (and there were many) and gave us perfect advice at every turn. We are only sad that we don't see her all the time now that we bought our house!”
Photo for 351 Spencer Road $240,000 Sold 5/26/2026
beds
 
3
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,248
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1665133
Photo for 135 Hudson Street $700,000 Sold 5/18/2026
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
sq.ft.
 
3,220
Buyer's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
Courtesy of:
Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc. (Downtown)
Steven Saggese
MLS # R1666396
Photo for 104 Valley Road $450,000 Sold 5/8/2026
beds
 
3
full
baths
2
sq.ft.
 
1,430
MLS # R1662727
Photo for 584 Enfield Center Road E $282,500 Sold 1/9/2026
beds
 
3
full
baths
2
sq.ft.
 
1,600
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1639987
Photo for 601 S Aurora Street $320,000 Sold 11/25/2025
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
sq.ft.
 
1,512
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1634720
Photo for 33 Strowbridge Street $348,000 Sold 10/8/2025
beds
 
2
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,280
Buyer's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
Courtesy of:
RE/MAX In Motion
Karen Potter
MLS # R1625948
Photo for 2219 N Triphammer Road $402,400 Sold 8/5/2025
beds
 
3
full
baths
2
sq.ft.
 
1,512
Buyer's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
Courtesy of:
Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc.
Emily Russell
MLS # R1609397
Photo for 5 Falls Street $245,000 Sold 6/13/2025
beds
 
3
full
bath
1
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,279
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1598298
Photo for 610 Trumbulls Corners Road $225,000 Sold 6/3/2025
beds
 
3
full
bath
1
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,440
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1594175
Photo for 120 E Enfield Center Road $190,000 Sold 5/16/2025
beds
 
3
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,128
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1593191
Photo for 37 Janivar Drive $510,000 Sold 5/14/2025
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
2,017
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1593182
Photo for 1307 Dryden Road $272,500 Sold 3/5/2025
beds
 
3
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,376
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1577847
Photo for 1937 Coddington Road $212,000 Sold 12/20/2024
beds
 
2
full
bath
1
partial
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,064
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1560686
Photo for 240 Owego Street $115,000 Sold 12/18/2024
beds
 
3
full
baths
2
sq.ft.
 
2,765
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1554975
Photo for 1464 76 Road $149,000 Sold 9/18/2024
beds
 
3
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,071
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1534322
Photo for 6428 Perry City Road $218,000 Sold 7/30/2024
bed
 
1
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
812
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1533751
Photo for 3142 Van Dorn Corners Road $205,000 Sold 7/10/2024
beds
 
2
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,031
Buyer's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1533183
Photo for 229 Valley Road $525,000 Sold 4/26/2024
beds
 
4
full
baths
2
sq.ft.
 
2,082
Buyer's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1521321
Photo for 5233 Oak Harbor Lot #4 $155,000 Sold 3/8/2024
Buyer's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
Courtesy of:
Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc.
Kathleen (Kate) Seaman
MLS # IB316804
Photo for 409 S Plain Street $235,000 Sold 1/16/2024
beds
 
3
full
bath
1
sq.ft.
 
1,174
Seller's Agent:Karen Small
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services
MLS # R1497344

Have a question?
I can help.

Are you pre-approved for a mortgage?

By submitting this request, you agree to be contacted by Howard Hanna via call, email, and text for real estate, mortgage, insurance, and professional services but not as a condition of any purchase. To opt out, you can reply 'stop' at any time or reply 'help' for assistance. You can also click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. You will receive a text message asking you to authenticate your phone number. Message/data rates may apply. This consent applies even if you are on a corporate, state, or national Do Not Call list. You can also click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. You also agree with our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy regarding the information relating to you. Your phone number, if you choose mobile opt-in data, will not be shared with third parties for marketing purposes. You can also view our privacy policy here: Policy Link