9585 North Otto Road
Otto, NY 14719

Est. Mortgage: $567/mo
Get Pre-Qualified
  • 3
  • 1
    partial bath
  • 2,250
Single Family Home

This historic home began as a Church in 1870, then a Grange Hall constructed in the typical Greek Revival gable front style; and finally a residence in the 1970's. Rooms are spacious, the 1st floor has open beam and joist ceilings. Country kitchen with new counter tops, cherry & oak cabinets, a 2nd hand wash sink; kitchen opens to the dining and living areas. A full bath with claw foot tub and shower; laundry room with space for a toilet. A full-width front entry foyer from the new treated wood deck, 2 stairways to the 2nd floor, with 3 BR and large open sitting room, spacious 1/2 bath, built-in bunk beds. The 5 ac. parcel is partially wooded, and has a barn with horse stalls and loft for hay storage; fenced pasture area. This home is uniquely styled and must be seen to be appreciated.

Property Details
  • Cattaraugus-Little Valley
    school district
  • 2 Story,Historic
  • $2,461.00
  • 1870
  • 2
  • B1094230
Electric range
Electric oven
Forced air heat
Propane heat
Country kitchen
Eat-in kitchen
Wood floors
Laminate flooring
Living and dining room combo
Full basement
Sump pump
School district: Cattaraugus-Little Valley
Detached garage
Garage spaces: 1.0000
Wood exterior
Lot acreage is: 5.0000
Irregular lot
Lot size: 389x591
Lot has barn or stable
Wooded lot
Lot number: 21
Gravel driveway
Well water
Septic system
Total square feet: 2250
Horses allowed
Bedroom 1 is 18x15
Bedroom 1 Level: Second
Bedroom 2 is 10x11
Bedroom 2 Level: Second
Bedroom 3 is 8x10
Bedroom 3 Level: Second
Dining Room is 10x10
Dining Level: First
Kitchen is 25x12
Kitchen Level: First
Living Room is 25x15
Living Room Level: Second
1st Floor Laundry Room
Other Room 2 is 22x7
Other Room is 6x8
Other Room Level: First
Number of rooms: 11
Courtesy of:
Concord Land Realty

Call (855) 464-2662

We are standing by to assist you.
Get more info or schedule a showing:
Name Type GreatSchools
Blossom Garden Friends School * Pre-School, Elementary School, Middle School, High School / Private N/A 5.58 mi.
Cattaraugus Little Valley Primary School * Pre-School, Elementary School / Public 5 5.5 mi.
St Joseph School * Pre-School, Elementary School, Middle School / Private N/A 5.99 mi.
Cattaraugus Christian School * Elementary School, Middle School, High School / Private N/A 6.25 mi.
Cattaraugus Little Valley Middle School * Middle School / Public 5 5.5 mi.
Cattaraugus Little Valley High School * High School / Public 5 5.5 mi.
Address Distance Sale date Sale price
9251 Otto Road North 1.2 mi. 1/10/2017 $96,000
9261 Wickham Road 1.32 mi. 9/5/2016 $102,500
10122 Meyers Road 3.83 mi. 5/27/2016 $127,000
9064 Otto East Otto Road 4.22 mi. 4/13/2018 $109,000
8185 Otto Road 4.24 mi. 10/26/2017 $125,000
10161 Point Peter Road 4.9 mi. 1/3/2017 $119,900
{"markerType": "ForSale", "lat": "42.41547", "lng": "-78.83591", "Address": "9585 North Otto Road", "City": "Otto", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14719"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.39827", "lng": "-78.83301", "Address": "9251 Otto Road North", "City": "Otto", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14719"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.43444", "lng": "-78.83935", "Address": "9261 Wickham Road", "City": "Otto", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14719"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.43797", "lng": "-78.76732", "Address": "10122 Meyers Road", "City": "East Otto", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14729"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.41788", "lng": "-78.7533", "Address": "9064 Otto East Otto Road", "City": "Otto", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14719"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.38948", "lng": "-78.76072", "Address": "8185 Otto Road", "City": "East Otto", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14729"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.44329", "lng": "-78.92422", "Address": "10161 Point Peter Road", "City": "Persia", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14070"}
Loading Map: Please Wait
Otto Real Estate Market in 14719
Properties for sale right now
Average sale price
Mortgage Help
1st Priority Mortgage

Get pre-approved for a mortgage now with 1st Priority Mortgage.

Get Pre-Qualified

The approximate monthly principal & interest payment for this property would be $566.55.

This payment is based on a 30-year loan at a fixed rate of 4.625 % - APR 4.699 % with a down payment of $5,750. Actual lender interest rates and loan programs may vary. Loans with lower down payments are available.

Use our Mortgage Payment Calculator to determine a more exact payment estimate.

Property Alerts

Be the first to know when properties in this area and price range hit the market.

Get alerts
9585 North Otto Road, Otto, NY 14719 is a 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath single family home offered for sale at $115,000.
Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither the listing broker(s) nor Howard Hanna Real Estate Services shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless. © 2018 CNYIS, UNYREIS, WNYREIS. All rights reserved.
School ratings are supplied by GreatSchools. School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Maponics. Both are subject to change.

* indicates a school is in close proximity to this home, but this home is not guaranteed to fall within the school's attendance zone boundaries. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.