Skip to main content

5189 Plaster Point Rd.
Cayuga, NY 13034

Sold 7/28/2017
  • 3
  • 1
    partial bath
  • 1,452
Single Family Home

This year round ranch is located at the end of a well maintained private road in a prime lakeside community.Kitchen and baths are updated with newer appliances, an open floor plan allows for entertaining. Sliding glass doors on the lakeside lead to new deck , a perfect place to enjoy wonderful sunsets. The newer addition has a family room with another fireplace which leads onto a covered deck, wonderful for outside entertaining. All public Utilities and high speed internet. A large 12 X 24 shed/workshop and a smaller shed, perfect for the watertoys. Dock is included. This home has a nice l

Property Details
  • Union Springs, Springport and
    school district
  • 1960
  • 307799
Electric stove
Microwave oven
Central air
Forced air heat
Natural gas heat
Wood stove
Cable television available
Eat-in kitchen
Wall to wall carpeting
Laminate flooring
Smoke alarm
Partial basement
Elementary school: Union Springs
School district: Union Springs, Springport and
Vinyl siding
Frame exterior
Lot on or near lake
Lot has lake access
Lot has lake view
Lot size: 58x226
City water
Boat dockage
Courtesy of:
Midge Fricano

Call (855) 464-2662

We are standing by to assist you.
Get more info or schedule a showing:
Name Type GreatSchools
Andrew J Smith Elementary School Elementary School / Public 4 2.44 mi.
Union Springs Middle School High School High School / Public 7 1.46 mi.
Finger Lakes Christian School * Pre-School, Elementary School, Middle School, High School / Private N/A 3.93 mi.
Frontenac Sda Elementary School * Elementary School, Middle School / Private N/A 2.14 mi.
Union Springs Middle School * Middle School / Public 6 1.46 mi.
Union Springs Academy * High School / Private N/A 1.83 mi.
Address Distance Sale date Sale price
5189 Plaster Point Rd. 0 mi. 7/28/2017 $282,000
5189 Plaster Point Road 0 mi. 7/28/2017 $282,000
3461 Brown Farm Drive 1.77 mi. 6/13/2018 $309,000
3461 Brown Farm Drive 1.77 mi. 6/13/2018 $309,000
3675 Parker Road South Road South 2.33 mi. 6/23/2017 $185,000
2887 Lower Lake Rd. 2.34 mi. 9/13/2018 $250,000
{"markerType": "ForSale", "lat": "42.8691", "lng": "-76.70551", "Address": "5189 Plaster Point Rd.", "City": "Cayuga", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "13034"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.8691", "lng": "-76.70551", "Address": "5189 Plaster Point Rd.", "City": "Cayuga", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "13034"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.8691", "lng": "-76.70551", "Address": "5189 Plaster Point Road", "City": "Springport", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "13034"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.85671", "lng": "-76.73604", "Address": "3461 Brown Farm Drive", "City": "Fayette", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "13148"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.85671", "lng": "-76.73604", "Address": "3461 Brown Farm Drive", "City": "Seneca Falls", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "13148"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.84432", "lng": "-76.73661", "Address": "3675 Parker Road South Road South", "City": "Fayette", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "13148"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.88582", "lng": "-76.74559", "Address": "2887 Lower Lake Rd.", "City": "Seneca Falls", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "13148"}
Loading Map: Please Wait
Cayuga Real Estate Market in 13034
Properties for sale right now
Average sale price
Mortgage Help
1st Priority Mortgage

Get pre-qualified for a mortgage now with 1st Priority Mortgage.

Get Pre-Qualified
Property Alerts

Be the first to know when properties in this area and price range hit the market.

Get alerts
5189 Plaster Point Rd., Cayuga, NY 13034 is a 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath single family home was sold for $282,000.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This information has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but no representations or warranties, expressed or implied, as to the accuracy of the information are being made by Ithaca Board of REALTORS® or Howard Hanna Real Estate. Anyone using this information without independently verifying its accuracy bears all risk for any inaccuracies. © 2019
School ratings are supplied by GreatSchools. School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Maponics. Both are subject to change.

* indicates a school is in close proximity to this home, but this home is not guaranteed to fall within the school's attendance zone boundaries. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.