Skip to main content

5150 Italy Hill Road
Italy, NY 14418

Sold 6/14/2019
  • 3
  • 2
  • 7,104
Single Family Home

Opportunities Galore with this Multi-Use Property..... Residential / Commercial / Agricultural. Property sits on 17 Acres, and combines both Living Space and Commercial/Storage Space all in one! 2 Apartments set up as In-Law Suite, could easily be converted back to single family. 5,000 sq ft Shop/Storage, partially heated, 200 & 400 amp Electric, 3-Phase Converter. Main shop area is 60x80, additional 12x12 and 12x20 shops are heated. And there's more! Additional building w/ horse stall, loft, and tack room, and a pond to complete the package. Well Maintained, One Owner Property. Minutes from Keuka Lake, Finger Lakes Trail, State Land, wineries, breweries, restaurants, etc, Come Take A Look!

Property Details
  • Prattsburgh
    school district
  • Other
  • $6,518.00
  • 1989
  • 1
  • R1182904
Propane heat
Ceramic tile flooring
Laminate flooring
Slab basement
School district: Prattsburgh
Attached garage
Garage spaces: 9
Metal exterior
Lot acreage is: 17
Lot dimension is: 1735X701
Out building(s)
Wooded lot
Well water
Septic system
New construction
Total square feet: 7104
Living square feet: 7104
Horses allowed
Number of rooms: 7
Courtesy of:
Howard Hanna Lake Group
Get more info or schedule a showing:
Name Type GreatSchools
Prattsburgh Central School Pre-School, Elementary School, Middle School, High School / Public 5 6.47 mi.
Naples Elementary School * Pre-School, Elementary School / Public 5 8.23 mi.
Italy Naples Baptist Church Ed * Elementary School, Middle School, High School / Private N/A 6.45 mi.
Pine Grove Mennonite School * Elementary School, Middle School / Private N/A 7.76 mi.
Valley View School * Elementary School, Middle School / Private N/A 9.02 mi.
Naples High School * Middle School, High School / Public 6 8.12 mi.
Address Distance Sale date Sale price
5150 Italy Hill Road 0 mi. 6/14/2019 $215,000
2535 Pulver Rd 1.33 mi. 8/16/2019 $239,900
2535 Pulver Road 1.33 mi. 8/16/2019 $239,900
160 Martin Road 2.41 mi. 5/3/2019 $170,000
3855 Wood Hill Road 3.23 mi. 10/30/2017 $195,000
4.01 mi. 6/14/2018 $204,000
{"markerType": "ForSale", "lat": "42.59889", "lng": "-77.24417", "Address": "5150 Italy Hill Road", "City": "Italy", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14418"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.59889", "lng": "-77.24417", "Address": "5150 Italy Hill Road", "City": "Italy", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14418"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.6174", "lng": "-77.25105", "Address": "2535 Pulver Rd", "City": "Italy", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14418"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.6174", "lng": "-77.25105", "Address": "2535 Pulver Road", "City": "Branchport", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14418"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.60688", "lng": "-77.29024", "Address": "160 Martin Road", "City": "Italy", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14512"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.62814", "lng": "-77.2936", "Address": "3855 Wood Hill Road", "City": "Italy", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14512"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.64", "lng": "-77.18856", "Address": "", "City": "Jerusalem", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14527"}
Loading Map: Please Wait
Italy Real Estate Market in 14418
Properties for sale right now
Average sale price
Mortgage Help
1st Priority Mortgage

Get pre-qualified for a mortgage now with 1st Priority Mortgage.

Get Pre-Qualified
Property Alerts

Be the first to know when properties in this area and price range hit the market.

Get alerts
5150 Italy Hill Road, Italy, NY 14418 is a 3 bedroom, 2 bath single family home was sold for $215,000 by Kathleen Higgins in the Penn Yan real estate office.
All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change, or withdrawal. Listings displaying the IDX logo belong to brokers other than Howard Hanna. Neither the listing broker(s) nor Howard Hanna shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless.
School ratings are supplied by GreatSchools. School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Maponics. Both are subject to change.

* indicates a school is in close proximity to this home, but this home is not guaranteed to fall within the school's attendance zone boundaries. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.