Skip to main content


Sold 8/8/2017
  • 3
  • 2
  • 2,198
Single Family Home

19th century Gothic Revival with stunning curb appeal on a quaint tree lined Village of Trumansburg street a few blocks from shops, restaurants and schools. Enjoy classic charm and modern updates in this 3 bedroom, 2 bath home filled with character. Deep village lot with gardens, natural area and large lawn. Hardwood floors, large windows, covered front and rear porches, front parlor, main floor guest room or den & a 1 car garage. Generously sized kitchen with exposed plank ceilings, pantry and dining area overlooking yard. Master with vaulted ceilings, skylights and balcony. A special home.

Property Details
  • Trumansburg Central
    school district
  • Victorian
  • 1860
  • 310023
Gas stove
Forced air heat
Natural gas heat
Cable television available
Cathedral ceilings
Ceramic tile flooring
Eat-in kitchen
Hardwood floors
Vinyl flooring
Smoke alarm
Walk-in closet(s)
Partial basement
Elementary school: Trumansburg Central
School district: Trumansburg Central
Attached garage
Wood exterior
Frame exterior
Lot size: 86 X 229
City water
Property style: Victorian
Formal Dining Room
Courtesy of:
Warren Real Estate Downtown Office
Steven Saggese

Call (855) 464-2662

We are standing by to assist you.
Get more info or schedule a showing:
Name Type GreatSchools
Trumansburg Elementary School Pre-School, Elementary School / Public 6 0.33 mi.
Russell I Doig Middle School Middle School / Public 6 0.33 mi.
Charles O Dickerson High School High School / Public 6 0.33 mi.
Namaste Montessori School * Pre-School, Elementary School / Private N/A 5.6 mi.
Interlaken Christian School * Elementary School, Middle School, High School / Private N/A 6.09 mi.
Lansing Middle School * Middle School / Public 7 6.1 mi.
Address Distance Sale date Sale price
42 CAYUGA STREET 0 mi. 8/8/2017 $284,000
35 Whig Street 0.24 mi. 8/17/2017 $281,000
49 WHIG ST 0.25 mi. 7/20/2017 $260,000
7 LAKE ST 0.25 mi. 11/14/2018 $262,000
34 WHIG ST 0.27 mi. 6/22/2018 $245,000
40 PROSPECT ST 0.27 mi. 9/18/2018 $265,000
{"markerType": "ForSale", "lat": "42.54267", "lng": "-76.65622", "Address": "42 CAYUGA STREET", "City": "TRUMANSBURG", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14886"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.54267", "lng": "-76.65622", "Address": "42 CAYUGA STREET", "City": "TRUMANSBURG", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14886"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.53932", "lng": "-76.65717", "Address": "35 Whig Street", "City": "TRUMANSBURG", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14886"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.53908", "lng": "-76.65564", "Address": "49 WHIG ST", "City": "TRUMANSBURG", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14886"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.54072", "lng": "-76.65208", "Address": "7 LAKE ST", "City": "TRUMANSBURG", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14886"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.53889", "lng": "-76.65731", "Address": "34 WHIG ST", "City": "TRUMANSBURG", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14886"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "42.54658", "lng": "-76.65635", "Address": "40 PROSPECT ST", "City": "TRUMANSBURG", "StateProv": "NY", "ZipCode": "14886"}
Loading Map: Please Wait
TRUMANSBURG Real Estate Market in 14886
Properties for sale right now
Average sale price
Mortgage Help
1st Priority Mortgage

Get pre-qualified for a mortgage now with 1st Priority Mortgage.

Get Pre-Qualified
Property Alerts

Be the first to know when properties in this area and price range hit the market.

Get alerts
42 CAYUGA STREET, TRUMANSBURG, NY 14886 is a 3 bedroom, 2 bath single family home was sold for $284,000.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This information has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but no representations or warranties, expressed or implied, as to the accuracy of the information are being made by Ithaca Board of REALTORS® or Howard Hanna Real Estate. Anyone using this information without independently verifying its accuracy bears all risk for any inaccuracies. © 2019
School ratings are supplied by GreatSchools. School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Maponics. Both are subject to change.

* indicates a school is in close proximity to this home, but this home is not guaranteed to fall within the school's attendance zone boundaries. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.