Skip to main content

419 W Lakeshore
Kelleys Island, OH 43438

Est. Mortgage: $1,574/mo
Get Pre-Qualified
  • 5
  • 1
    partial bath
  • 1,948
Single Family Home

Built in 1857, this side gable home reflects New England Folk tradition. This is one of several island structures that represent a tie between early and later quarry ventures on the South Shore. Elements of the architecture reflect its changes of use through these periods. Ownership is attributed to several residents including Addison Kelley and William S. Webb. Court documentation indicates it was built by George Calkins, owner of GW Calkins Co. Quarries. The front porch was added in 1927 and gives you views of Lake Erie, sunsets, tourists and a variety of watercraft. Located convenient to town, but far enough away from the crowds. The land/home is zoned C-2, offering a wide variety of uses. For more details, contact agent.

Property Details
  • Kelleys Island
    school district
  • 1857
  • 20163733
Forced air heat
Propane heat
School district: Kelleys Island
Wood exterior
Lot acreage is: 0.69
Lot has lake view
Lot zoned: C-2
Asphalt roof
Public water
Septic system
Tax year: 2017
Family room is 14 x 12
Master bedroom is 13.000 x 11.000
Bedroom 2 is 12.000 x 11.000
Bedroom 3 is 12 x 12
Bedroom 4 is 10 x 9
Bedroom 5 is 8 x 7
Dining Room is 12 x 12
Kitchen is 12 x 12
Living Room is 18.000 x 10.000
Laundry Room is 16 x 16
Number of rooms: 13
Get more info or schedule a showing:
Name Type GreatSchools
Danbury Elementary School * Pre-School, Elementary School / Public 7 4.56 mi.
Put-In-Bay Elementary School * Pre-School, Elementary School / Public N/A 7.82 mi.
Kelleys Island High School * Elementary School, Middle School, High School / Public N/A 0.82 mi.
Danbury Middle School * Middle School / Public 6 4.55 mi.
Put-In-Bay High School * Middle School, High School / Public N/A 7.82 mi.
Danbury High School * High School / Public 7 4.55 mi.
Address Distance Sale date Sale price
523 W Lakeshore Drive 0.04 mi. 10/20/2017 $289,000
121 Melody 0.13 mi. 5/29/2018 $270,000
121 Melody Lane 0.13 mi. 5/29/2018 $270,000
403 Sweetvalley Lane 1.61 mi. 11/15/2017 $269,900
218 Bookerman Road 1.64 mi. 6/12/2017 $225,000
702 Wesleyan 3.66 mi. 9/16/2016 $273,000
{"markerType": "ForSale", "lat": "41.58553", "lng": "-82.69617", "Address": "419 W Lakeshore", "City": "Kelleys Island", "StateProv": "OH", "ZipCode": "43438"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "41.58601", "lng": "-82.69592", "Address": "523 W Lakeshore Drive", "City": "Kelleys Island", "StateProv": "OH", "ZipCode": "43438"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "41.58723", "lng": "-82.69491", "Address": "121 Melody", "City": "Kelleys Island", "StateProv": "OH", "ZipCode": "43438"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "41.58723", "lng": "-82.69491", "Address": "121 Melody Lane", "City": "Kelleys Island", "StateProv": "OH", "ZipCode": "43438"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "41.60777", "lng": "-82.7057", "Address": "403 Sweetvalley Lane", "City": "Kelleys Island", "StateProv": "OH", "ZipCode": "43438"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "41.60519", "lng": "-82.71388", "Address": "218 Bookerman Road", "City": "Kelleys Island", "StateProv": "OH", "ZipCode": "43438"}
{"markerType": "Sold", "lat": "41.54342", "lng": "-82.73919", "Address": "702 Wesleyan", "City": "Marblehead", "StateProv": "OH", "ZipCode": "43440"}
Loading Map: Please Wait
Kelleys Island Real Estate Market in 43438
Properties for sale right now
Average sale price
Mortgage Help
Howard Hanna Mortgage Services

Get pre-qualified for a mortgage now with Howard Hanna Mortgage Services.

Mortgage information provided by:
John Shami
Mortgage Loan Originator
Direct Phone (216) 387-6451
NMLS# 215047
Get Pre-Qualified

The approximate monthly principal & interest payment for this property would be $1,574.19.

This payment is based on a 30-year loan at a fixed rate of 4.375 % - APR 4.449 % with a down payment of $16,450. Actual lender interest rates and loan programs may vary. Loans with lower down payments are available.

Use our Mortgage Payment Calculator to determine a more exact payment estimate.

Property Alerts

Be the first to know when properties in this area and price range hit the market.

Get alerts
419 W Lakeshore, Kelleys Island, OH 43438 is a 5 bedroom, 1.5 bath single family home offered for sale at $329,000 by Donna Schoonmaker in the Catawba real estate office.
School ratings are supplied by GreatSchools. School attendance zone boundaries are supplied by Maponics. Both are subject to change.

* indicates a school is in close proximity to this home, but this home is not guaranteed to fall within the school's attendance zone boundaries. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these boundaries.